It's Medical Monday!

Medical Monday: Mechanical vs. Bioprosthetic Valves

What Patients with Aortic Valve Disease Should Know

If you or a loved one has been diagnosed with aortic valve disease, one of the biggest decisions you may face is choosing what type of replacement valve is right for you.

It can feel overwhelming at first, but this guide breaks it down in plain language so you can walk into your appointments feeling more confident and informed.

First, What Does the Aortic Valve Do?

Your aortic valve is the “door” that lets blood leave your heart and flow to the rest of your body.

When it becomes too tight (stenosis) or leaky (regurgitation), your heart has to work harder. If severe, doctors may recommend replacing it.

When that time comes, there are two main options:

• Mechanical valves

• Bioprosthetic (tissue) valves

Both save lives. The right choice depends on your health, age, and lifestyle.

Mechanical Valves: Built to Last

Mechanical valves are made from strong materials like carbon and metal.

What patients like about them

• Very durable, often last a lifetime

• Lower chance you will need another valve surgery

Trade-offs to consider

• You must take a blood thinner (usually warfarin) for life

• Requires regular blood tests to monitor levels

• Higher risk of bleeding or bruising

• Some people hear a faint clicking sound

For younger patients, durability is a big advantage. Many choose mechanical valves to avoid repeat surgeries later.

Bioprosthetic (Tissue) Valves: More Natural

Tissue valves are made from animal tissue (cow or pig) that has been specially treated for medical use.

What patients like about them

• Usually no lifelong blood thinners

• Lower bleeding risk

• No valve clicking sound

• Fewer medication restrictions

Trade-offs to consider

• Do not last forever

• May wear out in 10–20 years

• Younger patients are more likely to need another procedure later

The good news: many failing tissue valves can now be treated with less invasive “valve-in-valve” procedures, depending on your case.

How Doctors Help You Decide

There is no one “best” valve. It is a shared decision between you and your heart team.

Doctors consider:

• Your age

• Other medical conditions

• Bleeding risk

• Ability to take blood thinners

• Pregnancy plans

• Personal preference

• Willingness to have another surgery in the future

Lifestyle Matters Too

Here are real-life factors patients often ask about:

• Travel / active lifestyle- Mechanical valves are fine, but you must manage blood thinner monitoring.

• Contact sports- Tissue valves may be safer due to bleeding risk.

• Pregnancy- Tissue valves are usually preferred to avoid complex anticoagulation.

• Medication access- Blood thinners require consistent follow-up and lab access.

Questions to Ask Your Surgeon

Bring these to your visit:

• How long will each valve last for someone my age?

• What medications will I need?

• What are my bleeding risks?

• Could I qualify for valve-in-valve later?

• What do most patients like me choose?

Sam's Summary

Mechanical valves- Last longer but require lifelong blood thinners.

Tissue valves- Avoid long-term blood thinners but may need replacement later.

Both are excellent, life-saving options. The “right” valve is the one that fits your medical needs and your life.

If you or a loved one is navigating aortic disease, you are not alone. These decisions are big, but with the right information and care team, you can make the choice that feels right for you.

See you next Medical Monday,

Samantha